Evaluating Apt/Lofts In Denver

This is Day 90 of the Slow Home Project and we need you to join us in our quest to evaluate the design quality of houses in nine North American cities in nine months. This week we are analyzing apartment/lofts in Denver, Colorado and today everyone needs to analyze as many apartment/lofts as possible.

Good morning Denver! This is our first day in Colorado and we need you to help us analyze the design quality of new houses in this city! This week, we are focused on seeking out apartment/ loft projects to review. To join the cause, all you need to do is search the web for floor plans of new apartment/ loft projects in the Denver region and then use the Slow Home test to complete your evaluation. Use the “Add a House To The Project” link to bring up the electronic version of the Slow Home Test. After you have evaluated the plan and made your comments, your results will be automatically added onto our Slow Home Google map of Denver.

To get things kicked off, we are analyzing a loft project at 2101 Market St in Denver called Twenty One 01. It is a renovation and addition to an existing 1920′s era food warehouse and the unit we are looking at is called the Vanderbilt. It is 1,525 square feet and has two bedrooms and three and a half baths.

The biggest problem with this unit is its site location within the complex itself. It is on an inside corner and this means a lot of the unit is internal and has no possibility of daylight for much of the floor space. There is also a potentially big overlooking issue from the other units that could see right into the bedrooms of the Vanderbilt.

The location within the overall building also negatively impacts the circulation and organization of the plan. It is really hard to place the living room furniture because you need to to walk through the center of the living room to get to the bedrooms. The location of the doors into the bedroom is also really poor.

The kitchen get a marginal passing grade but would have been so much better if the island had just been rotated 90 degrees. That would have made the access to the laundry room make more sense in the overall space and the dining room could have started to get some definition, whereas in the current plan, the dining room is really just left over space.

This unit score 13 out of 20 on the Slow Home test which means it barely becomes a “Moderately Slow Home”. Just a little more time spent on the design could really improve the livability of this unit. We would be really interested to hear what the Slow Home viewers think of the “Vanderbilt.”

That’s it for today! Join us again tomorrow for our “Which House Should I Buy” episode where we will be analyzing two apartments from the same complex to try to decide which is the better real estate purchase. And please, don’t forget to analyze as many apartment/ loft floor plans in Denver as you can using the Slow Home test and post them to the site! Your efforts will make a big difference to our project!

  • Mid America Mom

    Any new slow homers? Welcome to the project!

    John and Matthew told us about the walkscore. It is nice tool to find if a property is in a location that does not require a car to go to local shops, access public transportation, etc.. Check it out: http://www.walkscore.com/ .
    ————————————-
    ***Anyone live in Denver?*** As we found in Toronto it is nice to hear from local residents- our eyes on the ground (and not in google maps!).

    First plan coming up…
    Mid America Mom

  • Mid America Mom

    Hi John and Matthew — from the home page I am not seeing the add a house button.
    -
    If someone needs to find it- Click on the slow home project to the right to get started.

    Thanks,
    Mid America Mom

  • BradW

    MAM – first of all thanks for pointing out how to add a house because IT IS NOT OBVIOUS…also I thought it was somewhat interesting that in Dallas you found Buzz, a project with closets but no bedrooms, and now in Denver you find Beleza, a project with bedrooms and no closets. Maybe in Wichita, Kansas you might find something with both closets and bedrooms :)

  • BradW

    John,
    Further to my comment above…
    “Use the “Add a House To The Project” link to bring up the electronic version of the Slow Home Test. After you have evaluated the plan and made your comments, your results will be automatically added onto our Slow Home Google map of Denver.”

    Where is the “Add a House to the Project” link?

  • Eric S.

    Hi M.A.M/BradW,

    We’ll see what we can do about making the link to “Add a house” more obvious. Thanks for the input.

    Regards,
    Eric S.

  • Terri

    I also found it difficult to see the Add A House box. Perhaps the order of those right-hand windows could be rearranged? And maybe a contrasting background colour for the Add A House bar would help.

  • BradW

    It is not the Add A House button so much as it is the fact that you have to click on the Slow Home Project panel first. The blog above refers to the Slow Home Test – a new user and a slow old one would probably click on the Slow Home Test panel on the right to find a downloadable copy of the test but no way to add a house…It is fine once you have used it or if you have developed it but not so much for others…
    I do like the sorting feature and that the map goes to the selected project (having StreetView would be nice :)).

  • Aaron

    I just posted my first attempt at the Slow Home Project – aside from a bit of forgetfulness (I thought I didn’t fill out the form, so I filled it out again, but then it turns out I did in the first place) I found it pretty straight forward to use. Maybe a bit more connectivity between the discussion page and the “add a house” page would be nice (just thoughts!). Thanks! btw- love the site!

  • Anonymous

    Aaron,
    Welcome to the site. Thanks for joining the project and for the suggestion.

  • Mid America Mom

    Hi Aaron! Thank you for scoring two units from the Blueprint Condos.
    *
    As another contributor to the project I cannot see your actual test results except your final overall score and comments. I tend to agree with your comments. That plan 310 had lots of promise with windows everywhere. I agree they have this dead space near the entry.. hum…maybe put the dining there (or did you suggest that- I cannot recall since on the other page). Oh yes the kitchen does suffer from that island as you cannot go directly to and from the refrigerator and sink.

    Mid America Mom

  • BradW

    For fun I thought I would take a look at a couple of the high scoring projects…
    First up Beleza 1080 – layout and location are OK but when I read the amenities list the trouble started – here we have a LEED certified building with heated indoor parking for 296 cars??? Somebody must have been smoking LEED when this was certified…also the building is mostly not affordable

    Next the Spire Tower Speer – a very nice 2 bed/2.5 bath corner unit in a new downtown building – unlike the reviewer I thought the unit was well organized but would have deducted points for the laundry and second bedroom so probably a push – while this unit is good many of the more common interior units suffer from colliding geometries in an attempt to resolve the long and narrow problem plus bedrooms have no windows

    So I have two questions for you to ponder…
    1. Can a boutique luxury building win a Slow Home Award?
    2. Even though one or two units are nice can a condo/loft/apartment project win a Slow Home Award?

  • Matthew North

    Brad W – you raise some interesting points to discuss. I would say yes to both of your questions. I think a boutique luxury building could win a Slow Home Award because there are many boutique, luxury buildings that are built every year that are so horribly designed that we should celebrate this type of project when we find one that is well done. I also think it would be possible for an individual unit to win a Slow Home award even if there are other units in the building that are not so well designed – again – the point of the awards is to highlight the good work. My sense though is that if a project is badly designed – generally the overall score will be low for things like environmental performance and location – so the overall scores may be lower and that may lower the chances of the unit from winning an award. In general terms, usually if the building is badly designed, then so are the units – these tend to go hand in hand. Not a shocker I’m sure. i am going to have a look at the Spire Tower Speer to see if my theory hold true!

  • Mid America Mom

    BradW yes and yes. Same with a developer with 15 plans for single family or townhouse and they have many subdivisions and one good one in all of that. Beleza was hard to look at for size and price (2000 sq foot for a 2 bed!)and Spire has just one plan over 2000 (an interior family room with no windows) at the moment. Looking forward to your submissions.

    Mid America Mom

  • Mid America Mom

    Jennifer- I noticed you commented that ZiDenver was your first submission. Thank you for scoring two units from them!

    I agree with that Loft 2B dining space and entry not being all that well done. That master bath/closet/ and bedroom space – I think it is the same footage as my present two bedroom apartment! Little too much.

    Mid America Mom

  • BradW

    Well MAM, I agree with your comment. I think that unless the majority of the project is well designed then it does not get my support. I also think affordability is a consideration particularly with condos that offer over the top amenities that must continually be paid for regardless of use. I realize these are not Slow Home Test factors but maybe they should be things to consider – they count for my vote.