Miami Wrap Up

This is Day 143 of the Slow Home Project and we need you to join us in our quest to evaluate the design quality of houses in nine North American cities in nine months. This week we have been look back at our time in Florida, and today we are looking at your Design Challenge Entries, live from Miami!

It’s Friday and we are “live” from Miami! We have been traveling this week, first to Denver to meet and film all the Slow Home Award Winners in Denver and now we are here, in Miami!

We also have the results of the “Miami Design Challenge”. The goal of the exercise was to re-design a 1,500 sq ft single family home from the Miami area that was poorly designed to prove to the world that the Slow Homers know more about design quality than most developers. We received a record 39 entries and have narrowed down our choices to five runners-up and one winner.

The projects that did the best in this exercise effectively addressed the two fundamental challenges with this type of plan – the first is to create an open and visually connected living, dining and kitchen space. The second is to reduce the amount of circulation to the bedrooms and other parts of the home.

So, our runners up are:

1. Frances – note the great scale of the living/ dining and kitchen space. The kitchen is in an excellent location, backed up against the shared wall to the garage.

2. Tiffany – The hallway to the bedrooms has been detailed so as not to appear as a long corridor by shifting the door to the master bedroom closer to the center of the house. The kitchen location may have been improved if it was swapped with the dining room.

3. Marilyn – we love the hand drawn plan and think that the main living/dining/ kitchen space is well proportioned and very livable. The front entry closet may be a bi too large but the idea of combing the kitchen and bathroom into a large block is a great strategy.

4. Terri – we love the study location in this plan – what a great way to make use of the excessively large front entry space and to use some of the valuable window frontage in an effective way.

5. Sangeeta – the dining room works well in the center of this plan because it is still open to the living room and will have a view through to the back
yard. The bathroom “block” is an efficient way to organize the services but may have created an unnecessary hallway.

And for the winner of the “Miami Design Challenge” you will need to watch to the end of the video!! We have also posted all the entries for everyone to see below.

Also, to reveal who is the Slow Homer of the Week, click on the link below.

So this is good bye to Miami and next week we look forward to seeing everyone back on Monday where we are going to start our analysis of a new city – Philadelphia!

  • BradW

    Nicole – congratulations on winning the Miami design challenge

  • BradW

    Interesting article in the Globe real estate section – http://www.theglobeandmail.com/real-estate/prefab-and-loaded-with-green/article1599497/ – this is what happens when a couple of guys who we met in LA visit Toronto…

  • MollyK

    Hey BradW,
    Hmmm…and how did we meet LivingHomes in LA?…I think I submitted the 2 designs in the single family category. And which was my favorite video from the link you supplied in Miami..the tour of Ray Kappe’s personal home.

    It is unfortunate that the price tag is so high. But just as with computers, hopefully, the price for these “pre-fab” homes will become more reasonable as demand becomes greater. My major concern is how to convince people that these homes are not “trailers”. The term “pre-fab” conjures up some pretty bad images and preconceived notions.

  • Terri

    John and Matthew,
    I’m afraid you’ve given me credit for someone else’s bright idea to put the study at the front of the house.

  • Neogi

    Congrats to the winner, nicole and all of the runner ups, the plans are all very unique and there is something different i like in each one.

  • Bell604

    Congrats to the winners, and good job to all the entries.
    MollyK – Im pretty sure that anyone who looks at those pre-fab homes will be able to understand they are not trailers. Pre-fab can just mean that the walls, floors etc… are built in a factory environment. Shipped to the lot, and assembled on site. It keeps the product out of the weather, and reduces the strain and warping that can occur when traditionally building a home. It makes building a home like building lego’s, and is a very interesting process to observe.

  • nicole

    Thanks John + Matthew! I LOVE design books!
    What a great way to start the weekend.
    I’ve had a look at the designs, there are some great entries. Good job to all who participated.

  • JPHH

    Congrats to Nicole. All the design are better then the original. It’s nice to see so many people working on these design projects.

  • Deng

    It is so nice to see everyone’s work! Good job everyone and congrats to Nicole for winning! =)

  • bbhorner

    Congrats Nicole and Marilyn!

  • PeterB

    Congrats everybody, great work on your design challenges. Regarding pre-fab, does anybody know why its primarily only done in California? Climate related? I’m relatively new in terms of my knowledge of the industry and building practices in different North American cities.

  • BradW

    PeterB – pre-fab is done all over the world – in the example cites in the article the design was done in California, the construction was done in Winnipeg and final assembly done on site in Toronto

  • JessicaD

    Congrats to Nicole and all the runner ups! The plans you submitted are excellent and you’ve given me lots of bright ideas for next week!

  • Kadoman

    Congratulations Nicole.

    Some very good plans. I’m very interested to see that a lot of the plans had the bedrooms at the bottom. I know I tried to relocate them and couldn’t find any solutions, glad to see I wasn’t just unable to work out the solution, necessarily.

    I am quizzical about a main entry with two circulation branches though. Not critical, just quizzical. I have been in homes with separation like that, and found the circulation awkward and sometimes confusing.

  • Tara

    Terri:
    Thanks for pointing that out, the one they called yours was acctually mine. I suppose our names are quite similar :)

    Congrats Nicole – I thought the resolution in your floorplan was great.

    Have a good weekend everyone!

  • Terri

    Tara,
    So, that’s how the mistake was made! Good job, BTW; I agree with John and Matthew that using that wide entry for study space was a stroke of genius.

    Nicole, Congratulations on your plan–it’s very simple and uncluttered–makes a lot of sense.

    Marilyn, Glad you’ve joined the group too!

    Actually, I thought most everyone came up with fresh and original ways to reconfigure the space. It must have been difficult for John and Matthew reviewing them all and choosing a winner.

  • Terri

    BradW,
    Thanks for pointing us to the Mays piece on Living Homes now in Toronto.

    MAM,
    Good on you for commenting on the home’s design and rating it with the Slow Home Test.

    I do wonder if we can always transplant Southern California design to a northern clime. Too much glass can be a great heat-sucker. Even with the most energy efficient glazing, we can’t get more than R-3. Of course, with the geo-thermal heating/cooling and photovoltaic cells, this home should be harnessing/generating enough energy to mitigate its consumption in extreme temps.

  • Mid America Mom

    Thank you Terri-

    I saw this home over at Jetson Green last week and I commented there during the weekend. So just needed to tweek for comment length :)

    I know people may not agree with my assessment, as always, but overall it is a modest size green home (as we have seen for this market) with good design. *COMMENT on the PRICE* Toronto is one of the largest cities in Canada and it is pricey. In Toronto new construction CONDO is on the low end like 350 a sq foot. High end can go over 2,000. As for single family construction, that is rare in the city. This city does not have a glut of vacant lots and tear downs are known in that area of town. For around 750 per sq foot of finished space (this does not include the basement area which many turn into living space) you get no HOA fees, little or no utility bills, trees and ravine overlook, some of your own grass, a two car garage. That to me looks like a great deal but way more than I would ever be able to afford. I wonder what PaulC has to say about this as he is a local Realtor. For that money folks could look at existing homes in other expensive areas of town.

    Mid America Mom

  • Andrew

    Nice work with the hand-drawn plan, Marilyn. Also, congrats nicole, I like the laundry space you’ve created at the back entrance.

  • Grace Coulter

    Good job everyone, there were some really great designs out there this week. Nicole great job , Iā€™d live you your design. John and Matthew maybe next round of designs were could have an extra day to work on the designs?

  • Mid America Mom

    Nicole I forgot to say good job! I really like that master bath design.

    Mid America Mom

  • Hilda

    Congrats Nicole on the design!! Love how you organized the spaces and the flow of the house feels really nice too!!

  • Dan M

    Congrats Nicole and everyone else. Good work on the plans.

  • SangeetaG

    Congrats Nicole! you offered some great ideas and make good use of space. See you all next week!

  • Terri

    John & Matthew,
    Thought I’d let you know that the Ottawa Citizen article by Marie-Judith Jean-Louis was reprinted today in the Homes section of Victoria’s Times Colonist. Maybe other Canwest publications across Canada have already done so.

    To any Victoria-area newcomers,
    Welcome to the Slow Home site!

  • Mid America Mom

    ******Make sure to check out the facebook page – http://www.facebook.com/slowhome.****** Find content that can only be found there. Video of a housebrand home, our favorite pages (like Jetson Green), photos from our Toronto meetup and Slow home nominees and winners…

    Join us back here on Monday for another blog or try your hand at scoring a new construction condo/loft in the Philadelphia, Pennsylvania USA area.

    Mid America Mom

  • Matthew North

    Terri – thanks for the heads up about the Times Colonist article – John and I are still in Miami and are heading back to Calgary tomorrow – my Dad also texted me and told me about the article – he was surprised to see my face this morning as well while having breakfast!

  • DJS

    Really good work everyone. I really learn a lot about design when looking through everyone’s floor plans.

  • nicole

    Thanks to everyone for their kind + encouraging words. There were some great plans this week.
    Good luck next week!