Week In Review For Single Family Homes In Philadelphia


This is Day 164 of the Slow Home Project and we need you to join us in our quest to evaluate the design quality of houses in nine North American cities in nine months.

Happy Friday to everyone! This is a big holiday weekend for everyone in North America with Canada Day being on July 1 and the American July 4th holiday falling on Sunday. We hope that everyone gets the chance for some relaxation over the next few days and comes back to the Slow Home site refreshed for Monday when we start our 7th city – Vancouver!

Today, we need to look at the Design Projects that were submitted on Wednesday. This project proved to be a real challenge as there was lots of space to work with – and the fixed location of the stair required some creative space planning.

Click on the link below to see the “before” plan that everyone had to work with. The task at hand was to transform this poorly designed fast house into a Slow Home.

We have chosen 6 projects that we feel had the best schemes and would like to discuss them in more detail.

1. This plan is from Jim Baer – he did a modest renovation – eliminating all the awkward angles – and shows a high level of skill in space planning. Combining the back entry with the guest bathroom seems to be the most effective way to deal with this particular floor plan. The “formal” living space has a great scale and proportion.

2. This plan is from Murray. I would suggest combining the garage entry with the guest bathroom and shifting the front entry closet over to open the space up a little more at the front of the house. Moving the kitchen to the far left makes a lot of sense in this scheme and we like the idea of the millwork feature wall the that carries into the study desk area – very nice!

3. Tara created a long and freestanding kitchen in the center of the plan – this is a great concept and we imagine the potential for a lot of great detailing on the back of that kitchen wall (a book case, art gallery etc.). The lounge area at the front of the house needs a focus – maybe the bookshelves should run behind the club chairs.

4. We love Terri’s hand drawn plan – her front piano room has a great proportion – we noticed she moved the front door over to make this room more functional. Her scheme with an island kitchen in the original location is well done – if the fridge was moved a bit the appliance triangle would be perfect.

5. Tiffany has a great plan, but the kitchen really wants to be a “U” shape. This would clarify the circulation and provides better work surfaces and storage. The guest bath and front study may need to be reconfigured as the study proportion is getting too tight.

6. Finally, Jessica has a plan that really wants to have a “U” kitchen as well! To be effective, there needs to be clear circulation to the formal dining room and a “U” shaped kitchen eliminates the circulation problem of walking through the kitchen to get to the family room. The open concept study at the front of the house is a good small space alternative to a closed in room.

To reveal who we have chosen as the Slow Homer of the Week, click on the link below.


Have a great Holiday weekend and we look forward to seeing everyone on Monday in Vancouver!

  • Terri

    John & Matthew,
    I’m guessing there were no slow single-family homes to vie for the Slow Home prize in Philadelphia. I’m looking forward to our time in Vancouver–closer to my home–but I’ll bet the single-family home market is similar to Philly’s.

    (BTW, I realized my kitchen was badly planned after your tutorial on Thursday. Thanks again for your recognition and the continued instruction on this site!)

    Finally, best wishes to our American cousins for a happy 4th of July!

  • Matthew North

    Hello all Slow Homers – there is no vote today for the Slow Home Award for Best Single Family House in Philadelphia. We did not feel that any of the single family houses reviewed were of a high enough design quality to qualify for a short list – thanks for your continued efforts towards the Slow Home Project and we hope that the single family house category is represented in our final cities of Vancouver, Atlanta and Chicago!

  • Mid America Mom

    I thought we took a week off between projects – has that changed? I am looking forward to our next stop. Suspect we will not see much supersized.

    *****
    We are close to approaching 3000 tests in the project so far!!
    ****

    Terri I liked your plan, Jim I like how you placed that bath entry, and Jessica I love the family built ins.

    Mid America Mom

  • Matthew North

    Hi Mid America Mom – we are pushing through to the finish line on the Slow Home Project so we are forgoing our week off as we head to Vancouver!

  • SangeetaG

    [img]1_sangeetag.jpg[/img]

    I apologize for the delay in sending my files. I had major technical problems with the server and my files at work. My word files got corrupted when I opened them at work, and therefore I had to rework them. Finally, they all seem to be fine now.

  • Mid America Mom

    [img]dscf0119.2.jpg[/img]

    :) Wanted to share.

    Just downloaded pictures that we took at Luminato – a 10 day citywide arts festival in Toronto. They have have different kinds of art – music, dance, literature, design…

    The family and I went to the Distillery district to attend WAVES at the Young Centre for the performing arts. FUN! There we saw a short live drama performance, had a private audience with a resident musician, in a small group made up a song -rehearsed it – and sang it in the lobby, and the last thing was to go to a room to swing and write on walls! You will see what the latter looked like last year at their site- http://www.luminato.com/2010/events/152

    You could write anything you wanted on the walls. Our two girls loved it and so did we. I took the time to make a slow home :) I messed up on the baths and the laundry could be better but you probably recognize this general plan.

    Hope it posts,

    Mid America Mom